The Costanza Read · how this price compares
$1,995,000
median ask for comparable multi-family homes in Jersey City is $999,000 · based on 220 active listings
At $1,995,000, this home is priced ~100% above the median for its class. Priced at a premium — worth seeing what justifies it.
Want the recent sold comps on this exact block too? Ask Andrew →
About this home
In the same family for nearly a century, 74 Sherman Place offers a rare opportunity to own a remarkable piece of Jersey City history. Located in the bustling neighborhood of Jersey City Heights, with convenient access to Manhattan, this 19th-century Italianate Victorian sits on a beautiful tree-lined street surrounded by elegant Victorian-era homes. Set behind wrought-iron fencing and lush gardens, the home has been cherished by generations of family and admired by friends and local residents alike since the late 1800's.
A colorful tiled vestibule and stained-glass doors introduce interiors defined by soaring ceilings, intricate plasterwork, stately woodwork, and beautiful parquet floors—a level of craftsmanship rarely found in modern construction. These enduring details reflect the artistry of an era when even the smallest elements were thoughtfully considered. The formal parlor features a gas fireplace and etched-glass pocket doors opening to a music salon, where sculpted instruments adorn the ceiling. Across the hall, the formal dining room showcases ceiling murals, a bay window, and original Lincrusta wall covering. A butler’s pantry connects to the eat-in kitchen overlooking the private gardens.
The second floor offers five bedrooms, a bright home office, and a distinctive bathroom featuring a clawfoot tub and swan stained-glass window. The expansive finished attic, once.
The details
Property Type2-Family
StatusActive · listed 1 day ago
List Price$1,995,000
Bathrooms3
LocationJersey City, NJ 07307
MLS #260020985
Estimate the monthly payment
—est. / month · principal & interest
Estimate only — property taxes, insurance, and any HOA are extra. Get a real pre-approval →
Living on Sherman Pl
74 Sherman Pl sits on Sherman Pl in Jersey City. Journal Square, Downtown and the Heights each have their own distinct character. It's within reach of the PATH and the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail, putting Lower Manhattan and the Jersey City waterfront minutes away. The Holland Tunnel, Route 440 and the NJ Turnpike Extension keep the rest of the region close.
As a 2-family in Jersey City, it's the kind of turnkey listing buyers watch for — and in this market, homes like this tend to move on the first weekend. If it fits what you're after, the smart move is to see it early.
74 Sherman Pl, Jersey City
Good to know
Is 74 Sherman Pl still available?
Yes — it's active on the Hudson County MLS (listed 1 day ago) at $1,995,000. Text Andrew Diaz at (551) 235-3473 to confirm and book a showing.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 74 Sherman Pl have?
It offers 3 bathrooms.
How do I see 74 Sherman Pl in person?
Tap “Request a tour,” drop your name and number, and Andrew Diaz will text you back within minutes with showing times — including this weekend.
